Skip to content

· Thoughts

LINK COPIED

What AI changes for plugins: the flooded market, the big houses and the boutiques

Companion to HOLODRIFT: how it was made, and why "vibe-coded" doesn't describe it.

In the first article I explained how HOLODRIFT was made. This one steps back. What follows are opinions, not findings, and I have tried to mark which is which.

1. A flooded market

Yes, the market is flooded every week, and I can imagine how overwhelmed journalists and curators must be. I'm torn on the subject. On one side, the democratisation of plugin making is a small revolution, and among all these releases there are sometimes real gems. On the other, they are harder to spot in the mass. It reminds me of the early 2000s: the rise of the internet, music production on a home computer, the possibility of sharing everything with the whole world through MP3s. It was an exceptional creative blossoming, and I find it's much the same today.

2. The weight of the big houses

There is also a loss of power in this story. The classic coder is no longer the gatekeeper: many creatives no longer depend on that skill to see their ideas come to life. And I think the classic model of the big, traditional companies is running out of steam. Over time, size brings heaviness: less flexibility, less creativity, and sometimes major applications left to age. That is my opinion on REAKTOR, and on Pro Tools too. I wrote about Native Instruments earlier this year (Native Instruments: keep the faith — and stay grounded and What future for REAKTOR?).

What follows is inference, not proof. I can picture how, inside some big teams, resistance to these new tools may come less from quality concerns than from the fear of losing a long-held position. And I can easily imagine that some well-established brands have been optimising their production with AI for a while now, without ever saying so publicly, while nobody would think of calling their products "vibe-coded". When I see how fast some of them release, I find it hard to believe otherwise. I won't name anyone: this is not about pointing fingers, least of all over something I don't consider objectionable in the first place. I can't prove it, and nobody outside can audit another team's process. That is exactly the point: the label falls on those who are open about their methods and spares those who say nothing.

Boutique and community-driven makers are taking more and more room, even if the biggest players will keep their marketing firepower.

3. A label that means nothing

The line is already blurry, and it would be hypocritical for some to take a purist stance. A more relevant distinction remains "boutique" or "indie", and above all the question that really matters: is there a new idea here? I sincerely believe that in a few years, coding entirely by hand will no longer be the usual way of working, but the craft of a few virtuosos. For everyone else, AI assistance is a godsend for creatives with innovative ideas: a chance to make them real without being able to code. What matters is understanding the structure and the possible paths.

4. Hardware too

Even in hardware, things are moving. If Teenage Engineering really steps back from making synths, as its founder Jesper Kouthoofd recently said in an interview with Highsnobiety, it would be a big creative loss for the whole industry, which has drawn inspiration from them, me included. Theirs is a design philosophy that hasn't always been understood for what its creators actually intended, and I find it visionary and avant-garde. To me, they were right at the source of neumorphic design, and their way of designing synths has spilled over into completely different objects. Only their detractors would be pleased.

Left: my OP-1. Right: a neumorphic UI kit drawn in the same palette, with the same kind of controls.
Left: my OP-1. Right: a neumorphic UI kit drawn in the same palette, with the same kind of controls.

But it may be a sign that the market as we know it is about to change, probably with more boutique hardware, as we have already seen with pedals and Eurorack modules. Except that this time, I think it will be more about recycling and reverse-engineering existing hardware. Look at the current hype around a small machine like the M-VAVE FM1 and all its alternative firmwares, or at the iconic original OP-1, which has just been given alternative firmwares and modules of its own (maikopruett.com/op-1, hundekraft, opus), or at a site like altstrument.org. It is obvious that AI assistance will play a part in all this, and it is certainly already doing so more than we realise. My hypothesis: DIY is about to explode for good, and become the norm.

5. The plugin as a cultural medium

Instruments like these are usually seen as work tools, and they can certainly earn their place in a professional workflow. But plugins are no longer only a consumer good for so-called professionals and technologists by trade. They have become a kind of cultural good for many hobbyists and music lovers who don't particularly want a career, with all the demands and constraints that come with it. Jesper Kouthoofd put it bluntly in the same interview: "Ninety-nine percent of people who buy synths don't use them as a productive tool for making music. It's therapy." The only common ground between these two more or less distinct audiences is how an audio object becomes a source of inspiration.

I believe that the plugin, the app, modified hardware and DIY are already the contemporary medium of some niches, and the medium of the future, for musicians, audiovisual artists and producers. First, in the way we make and create. Then, because music is no longer delivered on its own, but always with visual supports that are more and more sophisticated, and more and more with author/fan connections, through the fields of interaction that today's technology allows. And finally, in the way it is distributed and sold. All of these perspectives are, to me, among the most exciting there are.

Conclusion

The big houses will not disappear, and the market will stay noisy. But the people who decide what gets made are changing: more creatives, more boutiques, more strange ideas that no committee would have approved. That is the positive side of this movement. An AI-assisted program can carry its author's identity just as fully as any other, and the same is true of the small makers who will build the next generation of instruments.

The funny thing is that the plugin industry follows the same social codes as a music album and many other products that have nothing to do with music, and the same ones that make it succeed: the niche it targets, the community it speaks to, the lifestyle sold with it. It's really a community thing. The codes aren't DSP but cultural language, the kind you use on a given project to speak to your people, your fans. It's all about belonging and storytelling. But that's another subject altogether.